BASIC ESTIMATING TIPS
Before beginning an estimate, you should make a thorough
inspection of the property, which means going through all areas that might be affected by
the remodeling at least twice. The purpose of the second trip is to help you relate the
causes and effects of conditions such as: a bad ceiling that might be due to either a roof
leak or a plumbing leak, but going through twice is the only way to check it out properly.
Or water in the basement might be caused by a high water table, but it is much more likely
to be due to poor control of roof and surface water.
When you are inspecting a property, prepare a layout of
each room involved, and of the overall dimensions of the house if necessary.
One-quarter-inch graph paper is handy to keep the job simple but accurate. Note the
location of all windows and doors, indicating the swing of doors, and the location of
electrical outlets, ducts and radiators, as well as ceiling height. This layout not only
will help you as you prepare the estimate, it will provide the raw data from which someone
else can check your calculations.
Particularly in repair or rehab work, where there are
existing conditions to be corrected, it is important to note the location of the problem
on your layout, to describe the problem, and quantify it on the spot. If a ceiling plaster
patch is necessary, a more accurate dimension can be determined during on-the-job
inspection than at any later time. All quantities and dimensions should be determined and
written down when you are on the job site.
It is more efficient and more accurate to estimate one
job at a time, soon after the sales call or the on-site inspection, while it is fresh in
your mind and not confused with some other job. Not only are errors almost certain to
creep in if you save up all your estimates to work up on the weekend, it is harder for you
to evaluate the judgement factors the longer you wait to prepare the estimate.
It is a very good idea for take-offs and quantities to be
clearly shown in your estimate, so that a second person can easily check it. One of the
benefits of the unit cost method is that a person does not need extensive construction
knowledge in order to check an estimate for errors in quantity, extensions or calculation.
If there is no one available to check your estimates, let them sit 24 hours and work them
through again yourself.
Every single element of a job must be included in your
estimate, with a cost assigned. Leaving anything out, even as little as 2-3% of the job,
can seriously affect your net profit on other items. If all the items are included, then
even if a minor item is misfigured the overall effect will be insignificant compared to
leaving something out.
If there is some element on which a final decision has
not been made, include that element with an allowance, preferably at contractor's cost
rather than retail price. For example, if a kitchen is being figured and the range has not
been chosen, a contractor's cost allowance of $600 might be used. This would go into the
total cost figure and be marked up by whatever percentage the company uses, with the
specification written into the contract as no specific appliance, but a $600 contractor's
cost allowance. If the customer selects a range costing $700, an additional $100 would be
charged. If a $500 range is selected, a $100 credit would be given, but the mark-up on the
original $600 would remain intact.
When you use allowances, be sure the amount is realistic
for what you think the customer will actually select. If you are figuring an
$15,000-$20,000 kitchen job, it is foolish to include only a $400 allowance for a
refrigerator. In most such cases, the customer is much more likely to choose a $1,000
refrigerator, which means that you have lost both the overhead and the profit on $600. An
allowance of $10 to $12 per sheet for paneling on a $300,000 house would have similar
consequences.
When you use a unit pricing system, there will
occasionally be items for which you do not have a unit cost, and sometimes your experience
will not help you. In such cases, the best approach is to find out the cost for materials,
add an equal amount for labor, and then add the mark-up. Of course, you must use good
judgement, and if the materials cost is very low then you will increase the labor, but the
1-to-1 formula will be adequate in most of these instances.
Your estimating system must work for change orders as
well as for the original bid. Contractors do not like change orders during a job because
they interrupt the rhythm of the work and are likely to take more administrative overhead
than they are worth to coordinate. Some contractors tell customers at the beginning that
there will be a $50 or $100 extra charge for any change order plus the price of the
change.
When a change order is needed, it should be written up on
the spot by the job superintendent if possible, then priced, and signed by the customer
before the work is begun. Change orders should NOT be done on a time and materials basis
unless absolutely necessary, and even then the customer should be given some idea of what
the total cost will be.
Try to have a place where you can prepare your estimates
without interruption, with all the references and materials that you need at hand. It is
especially important to have a calculator which prints on paper so that you can check the
arithmetic for errors and omissions.
You should go over all the information you have about the
project, and then begin the estimate, which should be done in an organized fashion,
probably in the same order in which the job will be built. When your first take-off is
completed, go over the plans and specifications again to be sure that you have included
all the details.
Checklist of Basic Principles
1. Decide on exact specifications and write them up.
2. Make a site inspection, identifying and quantifying
every specific step in the project.
3. Use a pre-determined unit costing/pricing system to
derive the total for each specific item performed by your own crews.
4. Where a unit price is not available, determine the
materials cost and labor estimate as accurately as possible.
5. Use a pre-determined unit costing/pricing system to
derive the total for every subcontract item.
6. Where a unit price is not available on subcontract
work, contact the appropriate subcontractor or supplier to provide the necessary
information.
7. Where the final decision has not been made on a
specification, use an allowance figure based on contractor's cost, or delete the item from
your bid.
8. Review the entire project and make a judgement on all
unusual job conditions, including at least:
access to work location
materials storage requirements
geographic factors including travel, parking,
jurisdictional licensing requirements
time requirements for starting or completion
crew's familiarity with the type of job, materials
customer requirements, including: negotiation stance,
standards of performance, talkativeness, neatness expectations, other idiosyncrasies
payment schedule and its effect on cash flow
availability of crews and subcontractors, current and
short term work load
availability of materials, special order items
presence of a third party supervisor such as an
architect, adjuster or rehab specialist
. . . then convert your judgement into a quantitative
adjustment to the cost of the job.
9. Mark up the job cost to obtain the price, based upon
your company's net profit goals and overhead requirements.
10. Have a second person in your company review the
specifications and the estimate, checking for completeness, mathematical accuracy and
review of judgement factors (if no second person is available, wait 24 hours and do it
yourself).
11. Refine any specifications which the estimating
process showed needed change, and dictate or type up the final specifications into a bid
proposal or contract.
12. If appropriate, draw the accompanying plan for the
project.
13. Submit the bid in proper form to the customer, and be
sure to include:
payment schedule
approximate starting and completion dates
license number
time limit on acceptance of the proposal
company acceptance clause
other qualifying requirements |